News

The Curious Case of Arun Shourie

– by SANJAY JHA

I am surprised that Mr Arun Shourie has not taken full credit for the Congress-UPA victory. While the BJP looked clearly rudderless, uninspiring and adrift throughout the campaign, the former editor of the respected daily Indian Express was the celebrated one who espoused the cause of Narendra Modi as Prime Minister right in the middle of the campaign. It is difficult to fathom what his real intentions were, but the constantly prowling for breaking news-media promptly pounced on that fleshy bone and made it into a leadership debate. The BJPs fast acceleration on a steep decline to nowhere got further accentuated. Frankly, it must have certainly confused borderline supporters of Hindutva, not totally supportive of a fascist intonation in their philosophy.

In the 1980s, when we were just getting into the political groove as college students, Shourie masterfully carried the image of being an incorruptible social crusader. He was the poster-boy of expose journalism, at a time when most editorial types were merely happy writing lengthy prose, albeit with a fine flair . Khushwant Singh was of course, the most entertaining media-columnist and editor, writing in his friendly conversational style. S Nihal Singh, Girilal Jain, Dileep Padgaonkar, MV Kamath , Kuldeep Nayar were all well-honed editors, who essentially focused on government inadequacies and political and foreign policy issues, with their own personal ideology not necessarily obfuscating the germane issues. Kamath came out of the closet in his saffron robes post-relinquishing office. Shourie played a more calculated game.

What no one , of course, ever knew or suspected Shourie of was his dyed-in-wool RSS links, an ideological engagement that Shourie deceptively concealed from us all, even as he raised a massive publicity blitz on Congress misrule as a “neutral” commentator. He intelligently created his own personal constituency, wrote unreadable boring books, and using the Indian Express platform, worked on demolishing Rajiv Gandhi and Congress regimes, which was anyway his principal goal. Shourie & co adroitly enough used “ alleged corruption” to capture public imagination and sent Rajiv Gandhi and the Congress into wilderness. It was the ultimate in flagrant exploitation of a media vehicle for a planned political assault, notwithstanding challenges within the Congress party.

Strange, but the same “pseudo-intellectual” ( sorry, Advani Saab, for borrowing your quote) was conspicuously silent when his own BJP President was caught napping or snapping cash on live television. Not a word was uttered on civil liberty when Tehelka was hounded using brute government power. And of course, the huge telecom slush money was quietly ignored.

It is a pity that Shourie’s frontage still holds a magic for some. Even the BJP , which was unforgiving on Advani for the Jinnah remark, has generally ignored the ex-editor’s classic faux pas, which substantially helped in submerging them in the elections.

Frankly, I like Swapan Dasgupta and Chandan Mitra; they carry their heart , head and ideology on their sleeves; no deceitful exterior, no false pretensions.

I only hope Mr Shourie is not the new-media hero, the Fake IPL Player.

3 Comments on The Curious Case of Arun Shourie

  1. “What no one , of course, ever knew or suspected Shourie of was his dyed-in-wool RSS links, an ideological engagement that Shourie deceptively concealed from us all” …
    This is absolute junk and baseless. Shourie is very much outsider to Sangh.

    Shourie did not conceal anything and has always been neutral in his stance. His books do not fail to criticize BJP also.

    Some people in which I will now include you also base their opinion on misconceptions and wishful thinking. Congress and especially Rajiv harrassed him as well as Indian Express and proofs of this can be found in shourie’s own book as well as commented by “neutral” commentators.

    We dont need Arun Shourir to prove that the history of Congress and its leaders is full of sheer incompetence and selfishness along with ignorance. No Surprise that Shourie gives you so much pain. He should.

    Take any of his book and prove him wrong you are welcome, but then the headless chickens in Congress are not match for him.

  2. Vijay Shankar // May 20, 2009 at 7:21 am // Reply

    Dear Sanjay,

    Arun Shourie has a proven track record of being a clean and honest man and substantiates all his statements and allegations with adequate proof. If you read his book on ‘Eminent Historians’ he will give you proof of all that tirade. You are a Congressman and you write on CNN IBN etc ( a lot of times with unsubstantiated statements stemming from your purported prejudice than anything else) , but no one should question you but when the editor of a National Newspaper carries out an expose with facts and evidence he needs a certificate of neutrality from the likes of hypocritical congress guys like you?

    There’s a line between prejudiced thinking and making sensible comments based on fact. Let’s come out and openly debate about the Congress and the BJP and we’ll see who wins. Are you ready to take the challenge?

  3. mala mejmani // June 16, 2009 at 7:08 pm // Reply

    Jha, you make me sick. You epitomise everything that is wrong with the Indian media — sycophantic, slavish, lazy , lying, unoriginal, repetitive and worst of all, boring. Stop being a Congress toady and go get a life. Even better, go get an education.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: